Montreal’s Contrecœur Terminal enlargement as a part of Prime Minister Mark Carney’s nation-building initiatives might ease t
raffic on the port
, nevertheless it received’t remedy the port’s greater downside: getting deep-draft fashionable container ships out and in.
Jean-Paul Rodrigue, a professor of maritime enterprise administration at Texas A&M College, mentioned the St. Lawrence River channel from Quebec Metropolis to Montreal isn’t deep sufficient to deal with more and more giant container ships. It’s designed to deal with vessels carrying as much as 5,000 normal containers, which is way lower than the usual Neo-Panamax container ships that may carry as many as 14,000 containers.
That’s a deal-breaker, he mentioned.
“It’s changing into very evident during the last two or three years as the scale of the container ship has elevated exponentially that Montreal is changing into marginalized,” the specialist in maritime delivery, port operations and provide chains mentioned. “We’re going to lose market share to the American seaboard. It’s going to ultimately undermine maritime connectivity of Japanese Canada. That appears to be what’s occurring.”
Montreal’s port
finds itself in an unlucky paradox, Rodrigue mentioned, as a result of though it boasts a superb location with perfect rail connections to the USA Midwest, it isn’t ice-free in winter and the price of dredging the channel could be subsequent to not possible as a result of huge value and resistance from environmental teams.
The Montreal port enlargement, among the many 5 infrastructure initiatives fast-tracked this month by Carney, offers with neither of these challenges.
The estimated $2.3-billion venture will permit the port to deal with 60 per cent extra visitors by creating house for 1.15 million containers, in keeping with the Montreal Port Authority (MPA).
Each the federal and provincial governments have dedicated $280 million to the venture, which incorporates the development of a brand new terminal on the industrial port of Contrecœur, about 36 kilometres northeast of Montreal, in addition to a railway yard, amongst different infrastructure. It was initially introduced in 2021 and is anticipated to be up and working by 2030.
Rodrigue mentioned the venture has been talked about for many years and will have been undertaken 30 years in the past when it might have been accomplished at a fraction of the price. Nonetheless, he mentioned, it’s wanted.
“It’s going to be a very good scale dimension; it’s bought the entry, room for enlargement and also you’ll have a really environment friendly modernized container terminal,” he mentioned.
Halifax, one other main Japanese port
, faces a distinct problem than Montreal and isn’t positioned to select up the slack both, Rodrigue mentioned. It’s a deep-water port that may serve a lot bigger container ships, nevertheless it’s farther away from main markets and doesn’t have the rail infrastructure to get items to market as effectively.
“Halifax would require large funding in railway connectivity, however there’s not sufficient quantity, so that you’re caught on this chicken-and-egg kind scenario,” he mentioned.
Each ports struggled in 2024, in keeping with a Transport Canada report in June.
The Port of Montreal in 2024 skilled a 4.8 per cent decline in container throughput, whereas Halifax had a drop of 6.8 per cent. These declines mirror broader world provide chain disruptions, significantly alongside the Pink Sea Hall, in keeping with the report.
Compared, container volumes elevated at main U.S. ports in 2024, reflecting broader enhancements in world commerce and financial situations. Key gateways such because the ports of Los Angeles, Lengthy Seashore, Calif., New York-New Jersey and Savannah, Ga., all recorded important positive factors after a difficult 12 months in 2023 regardless of the dockworkers’ strike on the U.S. East Coast and Gulf Coast.
Nonetheless, Peter Sand, Xeneta AS’s chief analyst, identified that Canadian container imports have grown by 43 per cent since 2019, a development fee that requires fixed port developments.
“Whereas Montreal isn’t uncovered to Asian imports at giant, and enterprise expansions with a non-Asian focus aren’t rising on the quickest tempo, it’s vital to uphold the best requirements for container terminals to be able to appeal to the enterprise and thus additionally to assist the native economic system and employment,” he mentioned.
Sand mentioned attracting bigger container vessels is all the time vital, however that requires dredging and extra icebreaking to make sure ships can reliably entry delivery routes.
Ultimately, new generations of extremely‑giant container ships favor deeper, properly‑outfitted ports, which neither Montreal or Halifax can fairly supply, Rodrigue mentioned.
“We now have two ports on the East Coast which might be going through precisely reverse constraints and neither of them are working properly in the long run,” he mentioned.
• E-mail: [email protected]
