As I flipped via childhood pictures taken greater than 20 years in the past, my eyes landed on an outdated air conditioner within the background, nonetheless useful, quietly outliving the guarantees of at present’s throwaway expertise. It was a silent reminder of an period when sturdiness mattered, when issues have been constructed to final. Imagine it or not, there was a time when engineering for longevity was a supply of satisfaction, when producers competed not simply on innovation, however on the reliability and lifespan of their merchandise. That philosophy has all however vanished from at present’s mainstream enterprise objectives. Instead has emerged a calculated apply often known as “deliberate obsolescence.”
What’s deliberate obsolescence?
Deliberate obsolescence is a method of designing merchandise to deteriorate in a set period of time, relatively than constructing them to last more. Merchandise at the moment are intentionally designed with brief lifespans, guaranteeing they develop into outdated, break down, or lose their enchantment inside a predetermined interval. It’s not a flaw, it’s a function — a enterprise mannequin engineered for revenue via relentless cycles of alternative.
First conceptualized within the early twentieth century, the technique gained traction through the Nice Despair when producers sought to stimulate financial exercise via repeat consumption. Economist Bernard London even proposed it as a authorities coverage in his 1932 pamphlet, “Ending the Despair Via Deliberate Obsolescence.”
Since then, the technique has develop into the dominant enterprise mannequin. This strategy has manifested in a number of varieties, all of which have helped outline the buyer tradition of the twenty first century.
Examples of several types of obsolescence
- Practical obsolescence happens when a product is deliberately designed to bodily degrade or break down after a sure interval or use. The notorious case of Epson inkjet printers refusing to print as soon as a counter hit a sure variety of pages is a traditional instance of this.
- Stylistic or perceived obsolescence performs on shopper psychology. Even when a product is totally useful, it might be deemed out of date on account of aesthetic or design traits. Apple, as an example, releases new iPhone fashions yearly, usually with solely incremental upgrades, subtly nudging customers to exchange their still-functioning units.
- Psychological obsolescence is carefully tied to advertising and marketing. Promoting cultivates a way of inadequacy for not proudly owning the most recent model of a product. Customers are persuaded not by necessity, however by want or the concern of falling behind socially.
A traditional instance is from the style business, the place manufacturers like Zara drive psychological obsolescence by continuously launching new traits, making customers really feel like their wardrobe is outdated virtually weekly. This encourages repeated purchases based mostly on vogue stress relatively than precise want or product performance.
- Systemic or incompatibility obsolescence happens when older merchandise are rendered out of date on account of incompatibility with new programs, software program, or equipment. A distinguished instance is when newer iOS updates regularly decelerate older iPhones, allegedly for battery well being causes.
- Dated obsolescence entails merchandise which are deliberately programmed to cease working after a set time. Mild bulb producers within the early twentieth century shaped the Phoebus cartel, agreeing to restrict bulb lifespan to 1,000 hours, regardless of having the capability to final far longer.
These layered types of obsolescence have collectively accelerated the speed at which customers discard and exchange items, fueling what some students consult with as a “linear economic system” — a “take–make–dispose” mannequin that locations monumental pressure on environmental programs.
Penalties of deliberate obsolescence
Environmental: Deliberate obsolescence accelerates environmental hurt by depleting pure assets and selling unsustainable consumption. In accordance with the United Nations’ International E-waste Monitor 2024, the world generated a file 62 million metric tons of digital waste in 2022, marking an 82% enhance since 2010. Of this, solely 22.3% was formally collected and recycled.
Improper disposal of e-waste releases hazardous substances like lead, mercury, and cadmium leach into the soil and water, contaminating ecosystems and posing dangers to human well being. Moreover, manufacturing new merchandise generates air pollution and will increase vitality use, contributing to larger carbon emissions and local weather change.
Social: The moral sourcing of supplies utilized in merchandise with deliberate obsolescence is a priority, with potential hyperlinks to battle minerals and irresponsible extraction practices. The extraction of supplies like cobalt in DRC for electronics contributes to not simply environmental degradation but in addition human rights points.
Moreover, the drive to provide low-cost, disposable items can contribute to poor labor practices, together with low wages and unsafe working circumstances in manufacturing services, notably inside the quick vogue business. For instance, in 2024, investigations into labor practices of Shein in Guangzhou, China, revealed that staff usually endured 75-hour workweeks, with insufficient security measures and low wages.
Deliberate obsolescence additionally has a notable affect on the affordability and accessibility of products. Whereas the preliminary buy worth of merchandise designed for shorter lifespans could be decrease, customers, particularly these with restricted monetary assets, are sometimes trapped in a cycle of frequent replacements, resulting in larger long-term prices. This cycle can create a major monetary burden and exacerbate social inequalities.
Governance: There may be an rising expectation for firms to maneuver away from enterprise fashions that depend on deliberate obsolescence and embrace extra sustainable, round economic system approaches. Transparency in product design, together with the meant lifespan and repairability, is essential for fostering belief between customers and producers.
Recognizing the detrimental impacts of deliberate obsolescence, laws and authorized frameworks are starting to emerge. For example, France has outlawed the apply, and the European Union is implementing “Proper to Restore” directives geared toward extending product lifespans and lowering e-waste. Prolonged Producer Accountability (EPR) schemes, which maintain producers accountable for the end-of-life administration of their merchandise, are additionally gaining traction as a coverage instrument.
A brand new wave of regulation
Governance failures associated to deliberate obsolescence are more and more below scrutiny. In 2020, Apple was fined €25 million by the French authorities for intentionally slowing down older iPhones with out informing customers — a case that highlighted how lack of transparency can shortly develop into a reputational and authorized legal responsibility.
The EU’s Proper to Restore directive, handed in 2021, mandates that producers present elements and restore info for home equipment corresponding to washing machines and televisions for as much as 10 years. Notably, France has adopted a extra direct authorized stance by explicitly criminalizing the act of intentionally shortening a product’s lifespan to spice up alternative charges.
In america, greater than 20 states have launched comparable payments, and New York handed the Digital Truthful Restore Act in 2022 — a landmark second that requires unique gear producers (OEMs) to supply diagnostic instruments and elements to customers and third-party restore retailers..
Towards intentional obsolescence with round accountability
For companies, the problem lies in transitioning from a linear mannequin reliant on deliberate obsolescence to a extra sustainable, round economic system strategy. This shift presents alternatives for innovation in sturdy design, the event of restore providers, and the adoption of product-as-a-service fashions.
The idea of a round economic system — the place merchandise are designed for reuse, refurbishment, and recycling — presents a promising path ahead. On this mannequin, deliberate obsolescence might evolve from a instrument of disposability to a method for managed renewal. By planning product upgrades and replacements inside a closed-loop system, firms can protect assets, cut back emissions, and nonetheless drive recurring income.
One core technique is modular design and disassembly, seen in merchandise just like the Framework Laptop computer and Fairphone, which permit impartial alternative of elements such because the display, battery, reminiscence, and ports. This modularity reduces the Imply Time to Restore (MTTR) and boosts buyer satisfaction. Life Cycle Evaluation (LCA) knowledge reveals that merely changing a smartphone battery as a substitute of discarding your entire system can lower embedded emissions by over 70%. These merchandise comply with Design-for-Disassembly (DfD) rules, utilizing mechanical fasteners, separating supplies by sort, and labeling elements for automated recycling, all aligning with ESG manufacturing methods.
One other strategy is the Product-as-a-Service (PaaS) mannequin, the place prospects pay to make use of a product as a substitute of proudly owning it. For example, at Schiphol Airport, Philips gives “Mild-as-a-Service” by promoting lighting as a service (lumens), whereas maintaining possession of the fixtures. Philips takes care of upkeep and recycling. The system makes use of sensible sensors to watch product well being, predict failures, and handle returns, serving to enhance useful resource reuse and meet environmental requirements like GRI 306 and ISO 14001.
Closed-loop materials restoration is a 3rd pillar, exemplified by Apple’s AI-driven Daisy robotic, which disassembles iPhones to extract 14 uncommon components corresponding to cobalt, tungsten, and gold, recovering over $40 million in supplies yearly. This allows end-of-life (EOL) recycling charges of over 90% for sure supplies and shifts the notion of waste right into a useful resource reservoir, instantly supporting ESG metrics in emissions discount and provide chain circularity.
Social initiatives like Patagonia’s Worn Put on program additionally illustrate round practices by encouraging customers to restore, resell, or recycle clothes, which fosters each model loyalty and financial resilience — key issues below the “S” or Social pillar of ESG.
Affect on ESG
To satisfy evolving ESG expectations, firms should combine end-of-life methods and transparency into their governance. Key efficiency indicators embrace repairability scores, circularity ratios, common product lifespan, and take-back/recycling charges. Corporations that report these metrics in alignment with ESG frameworks like SASB Requirements and TCFD disclosures are higher positioned to anticipate regulatory adjustments and handle reputational dangers.
Firms with robust ESG efficiency usually expertise improved monetary outcomes, higher danger administration, enhanced model popularity, and better enchantment to buyers who’re more and more prioritizing sustainability. ESG-conscious governance now means life cycle affect disclosures, repairability indices (as in France), and strategic end-of-life planning.
Extra importantly, it displays a shift in considering — from maximizing short-term income via alternative cycles to constructing long-term worth via product stewardship and shopper belief. The rising significance of ESG additionally displays a broader shift in direction of stakeholder capitalism, the place companies are anticipated to account for his or her affect on a wider vary of stakeholders past simply shareholders.
Conclusion
The outdated air conditioner within the background of my picture was not outstanding. It was merely made effectively and constructed to final. However in at present’s world, that quiet sturdiness feels virtually radical. Deliberate obsolescence has develop into a design alternative, a enterprise technique, and a cultural norm — one that’s pushing us towards environmental tipping factors and deepening social divides.
However it doesn’t need to be this fashion.
Via round economic system rules, the identical idea as soon as used to consciously drive waste can now be reimagined to drive sustainability and longevity. Merchandise could be modular, repairable, and serviceable. Waste can develop into a useful resource reservoir. Manufacturing and design rules can rework from being instruments of exploitation to changing into levers for renewal, if ruled with intention and accountability.
Companies should start to reconcile the profit-driven technique of deliberate obsolescence with the values of ESG. Customers, too, should shift their expectations, demanding transparency, longevity, and selection. Solely then can we transfer towards an economic system the place merchandise aren’t simply made to be purchased, however made to be saved.
For extra insights and steering on navigating the evolving panorama of local weather motion, sustainability and different associated points, keep tuned to our weblog for future updates and skilled analyses.
And assist us construct a extra sustainable and affluent world via accountable funding practices by changing into a member of the Advance ESG neighborhood.
It’s free to be a part of and there are not any future monetary obligations. Collectively, we will make a distinction in safeguarding our planet for future generations.
