US Banks’ Total Experience: Brand Promises Fall Short, And CX Is Declining

Banks create worth by profitable prospects after which serving them in ways in which deepen the connection and drive retention. Forrester’s new Complete Expertise Rating rankings for 25 US banks reveal that banks’ model guarantees aren’t resonating and that CX has declined.

So what’s going incorrect, and which banks are getting it proper?

What Is Forrester’s Complete Expertise Rating?

Forrester’s Complete Expertise Rating measures how effectively a model’s promise resonates with each prospects and noncustomers (by way of Forrester’s Model Expertise Index [BX Index™]) and the way prospects really feel about their precise interactions with the model (by way of Forrester’s Buyer Expertise Index [CX Index™]). Collectively, these rankings paint a full image of how effectively banks are profitable over new prospects and serving current ones.

Banks’ Model Guarantees Are Underwhelming, With Little Differentiation

Forrester’s new Model Expertise Index measures how effectively model notion, throughout belief, salience, and match, drives acquisition and retention for each noncustomers and prospects. Whereas direct banks’ model promise was stronger on common than that of multichannel banks, neither had been distinctive. All banks needs to be involved. Model promise impacts prospects’ and prospects’ willingness to want, buy from, and advocate the financial institution, in addition to pay a premium for its services and products.

Throughout the board, banks obtained considerably extra “poor” BX Index scores from their prospects than from noncustomers. This reveals a troubling actuality: An already lackluster model promise to prospects deteriorates even additional as soon as they turn out to be prospects and expertise the model immediately. In essence, familiarity doesn’t breed loyalty — it breeds contempt!

The Massive Image: Banks Battle To Stand Out

Solely six manufacturers earned the “main” distinction in Forrester’s Complete Expertise Rating progress grid, a map of how a model wins prospects and serves prospects. That’s not precisely a ringing endorsement. However right here’s the kicker: Most banks had been tightly clustered in a slender vary, making it laborious for anyone model to really stand out.

So which banks had been the highest performers?

• Multichannel vs. direct banks: Who’s profitable with prospects and prospects? Spoiler alert: It’s not multichannel banks. With a median Complete Expertise Rating of solely 56.6 out of 100, US multichannel banks are falling in need of expectations. Direct banks fared slightly higher, scoring 61.8 on common, largely attributable to prospects’ extra constructive notion of these manufacturers.
• Navy Federal Credit score Union was the gold normal amongst multichannel banks. Throughout the board, Navy Federal led the multichannel financial institution pack on Complete Expertise Rating, together with BX Index and CX Index rankings. Navy Federal’s mixed efficiency with prospects and noncustomers propelled it deep into the coveted upper-right “main” quadrant of our progress grid. Capital One, Chase, and TD Financial institution additionally positioned in that quadrant.
• American Categorical Nationwide Financial institution and Charles Schwab Financial institution led the direct financial institution manufacturers. On Complete Expertise Rating, American Categorical Nationwide Financial institution (AMEX) and Charles Schwab Financial institution led the direct financial institution pack, however USAA took the lead within the BX Index rankings and Chime was the strongest within the CX Index. Solely AMEX and Charles Schwab demonstrated energy at each profitable and serving prospects.

Belief Continues To Be Arduous To Earn

Incomes belief isn’t simple –– and for US banks, it’s crucial to attracting prospects, constructing sturdy buyer relationships, and making ready for the way forward for banking. This yr, the numbers paint an fascinating image:

• Clients assume that almost all banks are middling on belief. Fewer than three out of 5 prospects say that they belief their financial institution model; that also lags the business’s excessive in 2021. Navy Federal stood out, main the pack and scoring the very best scores from prospects throughout all seven levers of belief. For direct banks, USAA got here out on high.
• Noncustomers belief banks even much less. Round one in 5 noncustomers say that they belief the multichannel financial institution manufacturers we studied, and simply over one in three stated that they belief the direct banks. These are large gaps in comparison with how precise prospects of those self same manufacturers really feel. For direct banks, AMEX earned probably the most belief from noncustomers and Capital One led the way in which amongst multichannel banks.

The takeaway? Banks need to work on incomes belief — from their current prospects and particularly from prospects.

Banking CX Hits New Lows: What’s Behind The Decline?

Buyer expertise in US multichannel banking continues its downward development, declining for the fourth consecutive yr. The story is analogous within the direct banking sector, the place CX Index scores dropped to the bottom degree in almost a decade. The sturdy efficiency of physical-only CX stood out this yr: It outpaced each digital and hybrid experiences for the primary time. Clearly, conventional buyer touchpoints, equivalent to visiting a department or getting dwell cellphone help, nonetheless play a key position in constructing and sustaining buyer loyalty.

Among the many 25 manufacturers studied, just one earned a “good” rating, whereas the bulk landed in “OK” and two manufacturers obtained a “poor” score. Navy Federal Credit score Union retained its high spot amongst multichannel banks for the tenth yr in a row, however even this business chief noticed a CX decline. In comparison with its opponents, Chime was the direct financial institution chief, profitable throughout all three dimensions of CX high quality — effectiveness, ease, and emotion.

The Message Is Clear: US Banks Want To Do Higher

The excellent news? The roadmap is correct in entrance of them. Bettering model expertise and buyer expertise requires a deal with what issues most to prospects — and the flexibility to not simply promise however ship.

To be taught extra, Forrester purchasers can try The US Multichannel Banking Expertise Metrics Rankings, 2025, and The US Direct Banking Expertise Metrics Rankings, 2025.

When you’re seeking to benchmark how your model’s notion and buyer expertise contribute to profitable, serving, and retaining prospects — or to uncover the methods of top-performing manufacturers — join with me by way of a steerage session.

When you’re not a Forrester consumer, attain out to our gross sales workforce!